EFFECTS OF ANTIMICROBIAL THERAPY UPON DIGESTIVE TRACT MICROFLORA
Laboratory for Medical Microbiology, University of Groningen,
INTRODUCTION
(van der Waaij et al., 1971; van derWaaij, 1982) predominantly anaerobic
and/or in the intestines, either following
pressed, or not sensitive and largely un-
and mix with it to establish in the course
tentially pathogenic, are generally sensi-
of several days a steady state concentra-
tive and killed (van der Waaij, 1982). In
which may fluctuate with serum levels.
of the antibiotic(s) that have reached the
"overgrowth" (van der Waaij, 1979;
Nord et al., 1984). Such high concen-
trations of potentially pathogenic bacte-
fer of the concentration established.
invaded (van der Waaij et al., 1972).
tive suppression of sensitive bacteria in
This event is called "translocation"
the oropharynx and/or the gut, either the
SELECTIVE SUPPRESSION OF BOWEL FLORA
largely unaffected (van der Waaij et al.,
are resistant to the antibiotic used.
"selective decontamination" (Sleijfer et
this condition is beneficial as it is asso-
implications of antibiotic therapy for the
suppressed by antibiotic therapy (vanFAECAL CARRIAGE OF RESISTANT BACTERIA
cycline (Gross et al., 1982). In view of
the shift in general practice prescribing
testinal tract and not at the site of infec-
scription of tetracyclines decreased with
changes in resistance rates in relation to
association of those bacteria with oppor-
tract (Eickhoff, 1979) and urinary tract
so that direct comparison is difficult.
increased from 19% to 48% (Burt and
ence of antibiotic treatment (Watanabe,
Woods, 1976). A study of an extremely
studies from the sixties and early seven-
ties of the faecal carriage of antibiotic
resistant bacteria in normal individuals,
streptomycin (Gardner et al., 1969).
teropathogenic Escherichia coli showed
resistant to ampicillin and 29% to tetra-
ANTIBIOTIC RESISTANCE IN ENTEROBACTERIACEAE FROM HEALTHY VOLUNTEERS
antibiotic prescribing habits of 15 local
antibiotic resistant faecal E. coli in nor-
reported in 1966 (Smith and Halls,
the intermediate in adults and the lowest
in children of less than four years of age
resistant E. coli. Approximate analysis
portant factor. Linton et al. (1972) how-
ever, did not mention the fact that chil-
population (Leading article, 1974). Smith and Halls found in 19 of 20 rep-
riage rates of resistant strains in children
resentative E. coli from healthy subjects
chance of acquiring resistant strains.
ported both in the absence (Petrocheilon
carriage of antibiotic resistant bacteria in
of antibiotic treatment (van der Waaij et
(Williams Smith, 1975; Leading article,
rural non-farming families by Linton et
a very long time (Hartley and Rich-mond, 1975). The explanation for the
than the prevalence in children (64%).
also in a high percentage (63%) resistant
of the colonization resistance associated
flora in children than in adults. Whether
in the Netherlands (van der Waaij et al.,
intestinal contents (faeces) and may vary
where in this monograph, it is likely that
particularly as far as ß-lactam antibiotics
tivated by faecal substances (Veringa
lactamases (Welling et al., 1987) in the
ANTIBIOTIC RESISTANCE IN ENTEROBACTERIACEAE FROM HOSPITAL PATIENTS
surgery (Datta, 1969) was performed.
Gram-negative bacilli as well as E. coli
later Shaw and co-workers (1973) pub-
found amongst E. coli, resistant strains
either not treated or treated with tetra-
excreted ampicillin resistant E. coli and
34% tetracycline resistant E. coli. A
R-PLASMID TRANSFER IN VIVO
to receive R-plasmids in vivo is ex-
clusively be due to selection of resistant
habitat of E. coli is the human (and ani-
mal) gut. In the intestines E. coli is
fer of resistance plasmids. Whilst all the
riaceae genera other than E. coli tend to
tibiotic resistance markers to laboratory
adapted to free-living existence. Plasmid
den to Enterobacteriaceae (Zund and
Lebek, 1981). It seems likely that a
(Lacey, 1975). A rather recent study by
well-adapted organism like E. coli is
Platt and co-workers (1986) , reveals
that in vivo transfer may occur in hospi-
talized patients, particularly in E. coli
such as Serratia (Platt and Sommerville,
1981) and Klebsiella (Smith, 1976) may
sistance was not found (de Vies-Hos-
confer sufficient genetic flexibility to re-
pers et al., 1981), despite the fact that
duce the benefits of plasmid carriage. Bacteroides spp. are themselves capable
not prevented (Dekker et al., 1981).
to be a rare event (Bawdon et al.,
treated group in a study by Anderson
tion (Rozenberg-Arska et al., 1983).
amongst the bacteria of the faecal floraof a subject who had not received an-
(Petrocheilon et al., 1976). Most other
taking antibiotics, transfer is much more
likely during antibiotic treatment with a
plasmid transfer (Bawdon et al., 1982;
LITERATURE
Anderson, J.D., Gillespie, W.A., and Rich-
Burt, S.J., and Woods, D.R.: Evolution of
transferable antibiotic resistance in coliform
resistance transfer between enterobacteria in
the human gastro-intestinal tract. J. Med.
Ball, P.: Antibiotic use as an inducer of resis-
Datta, N.: Drug resistance and R factors in the
tant urinary tract infections. Scand. J. In-
and after admission to hospital. Brit. Med.
Bawdon, R.E., Crane, L.R., and Palchaudhuri,
S.: Antibiotic resistance in anaerobic bacte-
Dekker, A.W., Rozenberg-Arska, M., Sixma,
ria: molecular biology and clinical aspects.
J.J., and Verhoef, J.: Prevention of infec-
Berg, R.D., and Garlington, A.W.: Transloca-
acute non-lymphocytic leukemia. Ann. Int.
tion of certain indigenous bacteria from the
De Vies-Hospers, H.G., Sleijfer, D.Th., Mul-
lymph nodes and other organs in a gnotobi-
H.O., and van Saene, H.K.F.: Bacteriologi-
cal aspects of selective decontamination of
Berg, R.: Inhibition of translocation from the
the digestive tract as a method of infection
gastrointestinal tract by normal cecal flora
prevention in granulocytopenic patients.
in gnotobiotic and antibiotic decontaminated
Eickhoff, T.C.: Nosocomial respiratory tract
ing prolonged tetracycline therapy. Antimi-
infections: the gastrointestinal tract as a
reservoir. In: New criteria for antimicrobial
therapy: Maintenance of colonization resis-
Platt, D.J., and Sommerville, J.S.: Serratia
tance (Eds.: van der Waaij, D. and Verhoef,
species isolated from patients in a general
hospital. J. Hosp. Inf. 2, 341-348 (1981).
Platt, D.J., Chesham, J.S., and Kristinsson,
Gardner, P., Smith, D.H., Beer, H., and Moel-
K.G.: R-plasmid transfer in vivo: a prospec-
lering, R.C.: Recovery of resistance (R) fac-
tive study. J. Med. Microbiol. 21, 325-330
tors from a drug-free community. Lancet ii,
Rozenberg-Arska, M., Dekker, A.W., and Ver-
Gross, R.J., Gard, L.R., Trelfall, E.J., King,
famethoxazole for prevention of infection in
infantile enteropathogenic Escherichia coli
strains isolated in the United Kingdom.
leukemia. Decrease in emergence of resis-
tant bacteria. Infection 11, 167-169 (1983).
Hartley, C.L., and Richmond, M.H.: Antibi-
Shaw, E.J., Datta, N., and Jones, G.: Effect of
otic resistance and survival of E. coli in the
stay in hospital and oral chemotherapy on
alimentary tract. Brit. Med. J. iv, 71-74
antibiotic sensitivity of bowel coliforms. J.
Lacey, R.W.: A critical appraisal of the impor-
Sleijfer, D.Th., Mulder, N.H., de Vries-Hos-
tance of R-factors in the Enterobacteriaceae
pers, H.G., Fidler, V., Nieweg, H.O., van
in vivo. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 1, 25-
der Waaij, D., and van Saene, H.K.F.: In-
fection prevention in granulocytopenic pa-
Leading article: Transferable drug resistance.
tients by selective decontamination of the
digestive tract. Eur. J. Cancer 16, 859-869
Leading article: Antibiotics and respiratory ill-
Smith, H.W., and Halls, S.: Observations on
Linton, K.B., Lee, P.A., Richmond, M.H., and
infective drug resistance in Britain. Brit.
Gillespie, W.A.: Antibiotic resistance and
transmittable R-factors in the intestinal col-
Smith, H.W.: Mutants of Klebsiella pneumo-
iform flora of healthy adults and children in
niae resistant to several antibiotics. Nature
an urban and rural community. J. Hyg. 70,
van der Waaij, D., Berghuis-de Vries, J.M., and
Lowbury, E.J.L., Babb, J.R., and Roe, E.:
Lekkerkerk-van der Wees, J.E.C.: Coloniza-
Clearance from a hospital of gram-negative
tion resistance of the digestive tract in con-
bacilli that transfer carbenicillin-resistance
ventional and antibiotic-treated mice. J.
to Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Lancet ii, 941-
van der Waaij, D., Berghuis-de Vries, J.M., and
Moorhouse, E.C.: Transferable drug resistance
Lekkerkerk-van der Wees, J.E.C.: Coloniza-
in enterobacteria isolated from urban in-
tion resistance of the digestive tract and the
fants. Brit. Med. J. ii, 405-407 (1969).
spread of bacteria to the lymphatic organs in
Nord, C.E., Kager, L., and Heimdahl, A.: Im-
pact of antimicrobial agents on the gastroin-
van der Waaij, D., and Berghuis-de Vries, J.M.:
testinal microflora and the risk of infec-
Selective elimination of Enterobacteriaceae
tions. Am. J. Med. 76, 99-106 (1984).
species from the digestive tract in mice and
Petrocheilon, V., Grinsted, J., and Richmond,
monkeys. J. Hyg. 72, 205-211 (1974).
M.H.: R-plasmid transfer in vivo in the ab-
van der Waaij, D.: Colonization resistance of
sence of antibiotic selection pressure. An-
the digestive tract as a major lead in the se-
lection of antibiotics for therapy. In: New
criteria for antimicrobial therapy: Mainte-
Petrocheilon, V., Richmond, M.H., and Benett,
nance of digestive tract colonization resis-
P.M.: Spread of a single plasmid clone in
tance (Eds.: van der Waaij, D., and Verhoef,
an untreated individual from a person receiv-
drug resistance in bacteria. Bact. Rev. 27,
van der Waaij, D.: Colonization resistance of
Welling, G.W., Groen, G., Welling-Wester,
the digestive tract; clinical consequences and
implications. J. Antimicrob. Chemother.
Waaij, D.: Enzymatic inactivation of aztre-
van der Waaij, D., de Vries-Hospers, H.G., and
healthy volunteers. Infection 15, 188-191
Welling, G.W.: The influence of antibiotics
Williams Smith, H.: Survival of orally admin-
Chemother. 18 suppl. C, 155-158 (1986).
istered E. coli in the alimentary tract of
Veringa, E.M., and van der Waaij, D.: Biologi-
cal inactivation by faeces of antimicrobial
Zund, P., and Lebek, G: Generation time-pro-
drugs applicable in selective decontamina-
longing R-plasmids: correlation between in-
tion of the digestive tract. J. Antimicrob.
crease in the generation time of Escherichiacoli caused by R-plasmids and their molecu-
Watanabe, T.: Infective heredity of multiple
Guidelines for the prudent use of veterinary antimicrobial drugs -with notes for guidance- Guidelines on antibiotics Supplement to the German Veterinary Journal 10/2010 Guidelines Antibiotics1 are only to be used for bacterial infections. Any use of antibiotics (e.g. in human and veterinary medicine) can cause the development of antimicrobial resistance. The risk increases if antibiotics ar